Not My China

Filed under: China, Thoughts — megan at 11:48 pm on Tuesday, April 24, 2007

My students this term have a tendency to say “My China” or “Our China”. As their oral English teacher, that bothers me. Who says that? I would never say “My United States” (that just reminded me of a song though) or “Our United States of America”.
I just thought that it had a strange sound to it. When students used that phrase, I let it go, but I must say I didn’t like it.

On Friday afternoon, I biked with seven of my students to XiaoLong. I’ve been there a few times before, it’s one of my favorite places around Yizhou- refreshingly clean and beautiful. However, I’ve always taken a bus. Who knew that a 15 minute bus ride could turn into an hour long, mostly uphill fight with a rented, rusty bike and students who are not good at biking? (Who knew that was a possibility in China?)
During one of our short breaks to catch our breath, I was having a conversation with one of the students. During our discussion, he referred to “Our China”, so I asked him about it. I told him that I had observed that most students use those same words.

He told me that it most likely comes from the old idea that China is the greatest country in the world and that China only belongs to the Chinese and no one else. It is simply to emphasize that China does not belong to anyone else and it’s a way of expressing pride in the country.

It was a mild shock to have it so clearly pointed out to me.

I’m not completely ignorant, in case you weren’t sure. I know that I’m not actually Chinese. I realize that I have a contract to be here for two years and once that contract ends, I will most likely return back to the U.S.A.
However, the difficult part to swallow is the knowledge that even if I wanted to spend the rest of my life in China, it would never really be “My China”. Even if I spoke fluent Mandarin, or even the local dialect, I would never really belong here.

It’s strange to think that I was born an American and no matter what happens, I’ll always be considered an American, no matter where I choose to live the remaining days of my life. I may disagree with the President, the Courts, or my local Representative. It won’t matter- I will still be held accountable by the decisions made back the The States.
I didn’t make that choice.

I guess that I spent my youth deceived by the idea that I could be whoever I wanted to be and whatever I wanted to be as long as I worked hard enough to do it.
It has taken me years, but I’ve finally come to the realization that it’s not entirely true.
There are many things that I will never be, and Chinese is one of those.
I’m reminded of it every single day.

XiaoLong Bridge on a Rainy Day

12 Comments »

3

Comment by cynthia

April 25, 2007 @ 2:51 am

That is a beautiful picture!

4

Comment by Triskana

April 25, 2007 @ 4:16 am

Very wise observation, Megan, and something that I don’t think about much until my British-native husband speaks about an ‘American’ thing as an ‘outsider’. We do not know much about our place on this planet until we leave the cozy familiar surroundings that we call our own. I laud your courage to be there in China as an outsider, yet providing such a wonderful volunteer service to those who strive to learn the language that we know as our own.

Peace and love to you,
Triskana

5

Comment by Mark

April 25, 2007 @ 4:19 am

I came to understand recently that China means “our land.” I am not sure if that is true or not if it is true it would fit why residents there would say “our China.”

True, you can not be everything you think you could be. Try hard as you might you will never be an Elm Tree or a Jellyfish. You can always be more knowledgeable, more understanding, more patient etc.

Do not impose limits on yourself.

6

Comment by Leslie

April 25, 2007 @ 5:58 am

How rude. Perhaps not entirely, but I would think of it as rude. Or unwelcoming. Someone should notify the tourism industry there. :P

Hope you are doing well otherwise.

7

Comment by megan

April 25, 2007 @ 7:02 am

Mark, actually, the Chinese for China is 中国- in pinyin, that is zhong guo.
The second character (guo) means country.
The first is zhong, which means something like middle or center.
So it translates as something like “middle country”.

8

Comment by angela

April 25, 2007 @ 7:16 am

“if i could go back in time, i’d want to meet snoopy”

i dont know why, but the whole thinkingyoucanbe/doanythingyouwant reminded me of that quote from josie and the pussycats

9

Comment by Joe Frederick

April 25, 2007 @ 9:17 am

quick note,

i havent heard anyone say “my china” here in hubei china, however whenever i do complain about the way something is done in china, i’ve been told “if you no like, go back (your) america”

thought i should share that

10

Comment by Beth

April 25, 2007 @ 9:55 am

Megan,

What a wonderful site! It will be great to read postings again from you!

Love you!!!

11

Comment by Tamika

April 25, 2007 @ 12:07 pm

You know, from what I gather (especially with my husband being Korean and me definitely NOT falling into that category) is that most Asian cultures are more closed-off to outsiders than other places, and make it a point to establish the difference between “us” and “them.” Don’t take it personally—unless the person doing the alienating happens to be your mother in law and she won’t leave you the hell alone, as in my case. :-) Best of luck to you in your travels, and that picture is GORGEOUS!! Love it.

12

Comment by Tara

April 25, 2007 @ 9:42 pm

Hi Megan!
Love the new site & that picture! Beautiful!

Please don’t feel like you can’t be or do what you want to do in life. You can do anything you dream of. Yes, you are an American and will probably always be looked at as an American, but that shouldn’t stop you from being you or striving to do what you feel is right. I wish the best for you in all you do!

Love you bunches!

13

Comment by Mark Rich

April 25, 2007 @ 11:12 pm

Hey, Megan!

I’ve known other instances of this same phenomenon. I started ministry in North Dakota, and the women complained that, if they hadn’t been born in that small community but came from outside it — even just from elsewhere in North Dakota — they were considered outsiders, and that after 30 or 40 years of marriage, living in the community, having children and raising them there.

There are many cultures (most cultures? ALL cultures??) that have insularity built into them. A pastor I knew in ND told me once how he had been previously married to a Norwegian woman and had gone to live with her in Norway for a few years. He said that the Norwegians simply couldn’t comprehend him when he said that he didn’t agree with them, or saw things differently. As they saw it, their way was not merely the best way, but the only real way to do and to think and to feel.

I can only imagine what that must do for Chinese when that insularity is joined with their understanding of themselves as the “center country”, i.e., the country at the center of the world. And what does that do to other countries that contain the axis mundi, whether it be Mecca or Jerusalem or Rome or Washington, D.C.?

BTW, Megan, we are today putting up the letters from your students in the Fellowship Hall. (A nice counterbalance to the insularity, no?) Folks here are thrilled to see them, and are more than a little proud of you for making all this happen!

In peace,
Pr. Mark

14

Comment by Emma

April 26, 2007 @ 10:55 pm

Hey Megan!
Great to see your new site,it’s beautiful!
As a Chinese,I’m afraid that I have to defend a little .It might be offensive when you hear Chinese say “our Chinese” all the time.But it’s only a fixed Chinese way of expressing ,most people don’t mean to be proud or anything malicious.We also have the fixed expressing way like “our province”,”our zone” ,including “our country”.Don’t take it too serious.
Megan,you have always appeared to me such a sweet and smart girl ,and I never get any further away from you because you are an American .I cherish you even more since we have absorbed different cultures and have different ways of thinking.I believe all the students and the friends around you think in this way.Remember the word “awesome”you taught me,I’m afraid there’s no more words more suitable for you.
Love you !!!

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>